Not Enough Words

by Tommy Walker

What "Not Enough Words" means

The title is not a literary device. It is a pastoral report from a specific kind of grief. Tommy Walker wrote this song for the moments in ministry where the usual language fails. Where the vocabulary of comfort, which gets deployed automatically and often too quickly, bumps up against a loss that is simply too large for it. Miscarriage. The death of a child. A trauma that leaves the grieving person sitting inside a silence that words cannot bridge. The title names that silence as the primary experience rather than reaching past it toward resolution. This is a significant choice. Most worship songs about grief move quickly through the valley toward the light. "Not Enough Words" does something more honest. It stays with the not-enough-ness. It names the inadequacy of language itself as a form of solidarity with the person in the loss. The song is not about the absence of God in grief. It is about the adequacy of presence when words have run out. When God shows up in silence. When the most truthful thing you can offer a person in grief is not more explanation but proximity. Leading this song is one of the most pastorally demanding things a worship leader can do. You are not leading a congregation toward joy. You are leading them toward a grief that is held, which is a different kind of arrival.

What this song does in a room

At 66 BPM, the song moves at almost exactly the pace of a quiet heartbeat. That is not incidental. The tempo creates a physiological quality of rest, or at least of slowing, that the body registers before the mind does. A room singing this song tends to go very quiet. Not in the way of distraction or disengagement, but in the way of concentration. The congregants who are in active grief will find this song creates a container for what they have been carrying without anywhere to put it. The congregants who are not in active grief but who have known loss will re-enter memories. The congregants who have never experienced this particular grief may encounter, for the first time, language for what they will eventually need. All three of those experiences can happen simultaneously in a room, and the song holds them together without demanding that any of them resolve prematurely. You will likely see tears. You should expect them and not be unsettled by them. Tears in this context are not a sign that something went wrong. They are evidence that the song is doing what it is built to do.

What this song is saying about God

The song is not making a triumphant claim about God's power. It is making a claim about God's presence. That presence does not require explanation or justification. It does not attempt to make grief make sense. It shows up. It sits with. It does not rush toward resolution or platitude. The God this song is singing about is the God of Psalm 34:18: "close to the brokenhearted." Close is a proximity word, not a performance word. The God of this song does not arrive with answers. He arrives. That is the claim. And for the person in deep grief, that claim is either the most offensive thing imaginable, if the presence has not been felt, or the only thing that has been holding them together, if it has. The song is careful not to oversell. It does not claim that God's presence makes the grief smaller. It claims that the presence is real, which is all you can truthfully say. Leading this song, you are not arguing theology. You are offering solidarity in the form of music. You are saying: your grief is not too large for this room, and the God you are singing to is not frightened of it.

Scriptural backbone

Psalm 34:18 is the center: "The Lord is close to the brokenhearted and saves those who are crushed in spirit." The closeness is not metaphorical in the Psalm. It is the same word used for physical proximity. God near the broken. Not above the broken, not watching the broken from a safe interpretive distance. Near. Lamentations 3:22-23 gives the song its stability: "Because of the Lord's great love we are not consumed, for his compassions never fail. They are new every morning; great is your faithfulness." The Lamentations writer is in the middle of national catastrophe, not looking back from safety. The declaration of faithfulness is made from inside the wreckage. That is where this song lives. Romans 8:26 adds the pneumatological note: "In the same way, the Spirit helps us in our weakness. We do not know what we ought to pray for, but the Spirit himself intercedes for us through wordless groans." Wordless groans. The Spirit himself does not always use words in the face of loss. The song's title is giving you permission for the same.

How to use it in a service

This song should not appear in a service unless the service has been specifically shaped around grief, loss, or lament. It does not work as a pivot song or a bridge between heavier and lighter content. It requires a service that has been built around the experience of grief, not one in which grief is a topic briefly visited. Use it in memorial services, in services following a community tragedy, in a service specifically offered for those who have experienced pregnancy loss or the death of a child. Use it on Sundays when the preacher has walked the congregation through a text that sits in lament, Lamentations, the Psalms of ascent, Job, the passion narratives. Before using this song, spend time with the congregation's pastoral leadership making sure the service as a whole is equipped to hold what the song opens. This song can open things in people that need tending. Make sure the tending is available, through prayer teams, pastoral presence, adequate time, before you put this song in a set.

Things to watch for as the worship leader

Your face will matter more in this song than in any other. If you look uncomfortable with grief, the congregation will feel unsafe being present to their own. Practice leading this song with your eyes open, not in performative emotion but in genuine, pastoral presence. The tendency for worship leaders in grief songs is one of two failures. Either the leader distances from the emotion and leads from a kind of detached professionalism that signals to the congregation that this is not a real space for real grief. Or the leader overcomes the emotional content and becomes so visibly overwhelmed that the congregation's attention shifts from their own experience to the leader's. Neither serves the room. What you are aiming for is present and steady. You are with them. You have not been undone. Both of those things need to be visible. Watch also for the temptation to speak too much between sections. A brief invitation before the song, one sentence, is enough. The words of the song are doing the work. Trust them.

A note for the team behind you (techs, vocalists, band)

This is a song for the quietest version of your instrument. Drummers: brushes or light rods. No kick pattern heavier than what you absolutely need. This song does not need a driving pulse. It needs a heartbeat. If your arrangement allows it, consider removing percussion entirely on the first verse and bringing in very light brushwork beginning at the chorus. Bassists: sustain, warmth, and minimal movement. The low end should be felt rather than heard. Guitarists: a clean acoustic or a clean electric with significant reverb. Single notes or very sparse arpeggiated figures rather than chord strumming. Keys: the pad is carrying the emotional atmosphere. Choose something warm and non-intrusive. If you have an acoustic piano and you are in a room with natural reverb, sparse piano notes, widely spaced, can do more than a fully produced arrangement. Vocalists: this is a song where backing vocals should be barely present or absent entirely. The lead vocal should feel alone at first. If harmonies enter, they should feel like the arrival of accompaniment rather than the presence of a full ensemble. Techs: the most important thing you can do is protect the intimacy of the room. If you have any feedback issues in the low frequencies, address them before the service. The last thing a grieving room needs is a technical disruption during this song. Keep the front-of-house mix intimate and present. Lighting: low and warm. No change during the song if you can help it. Stability of environment matters to people who are in grief.

Scripture References

  • Romans 8:26-27
  • Psalm 22:1-2

Themes

Tags