And Can It Be That I Should Gain

Theology & Meaning

One of Charles Wesley's greatest hymns of wonder at the atonement—the infinite condescension of God in Christ dying for sinners. Each stanza deepens the theological astonishment: 'Amazing love! How can it be / That Thou, my God, shouldst die for me?' The final stanza celebrates justification and bold access to God's throne.

Worship Leadership Tips

Deeply evangelistic and devotional. Works powerfully after a message on the cross or Romans 5. The congregation should be encouraged to sit with the wonder of the text. The final stanza ('No condemnation now I dread') deserves a triumphant rendering. Strong as a communion hymn.

Arrangement Tips

Piano or organ traditionally. Contemporary arrangements work with driving 4/4 rhythm and guitar. The tune 'Sagina' is strong and memorable. The ascending melodic line in the final phrase builds naturally. Choir harmonies in all four parts add grandeur to the 'Amazing love' refrain.

Scripture References

• Romans 5:8-10
• Galatians 2:20
• Acts 16:26